TLDR Review: "Valuetoner Ink Cartridge Replacement for HP 98 (Black, 2 Pack)"
Pros
- •Cartridge lasts a long time, with frequent home use lasting about 9 months on average.
- •Easy installation process that includes an alignment page for optimal setup.
- •Print quality remains consistent with no degradation, even after printing large volumes initially.
- •Fits well in printers designed for original HP 98 cartridges, including XL replacements.
- •Secure and protective packaging closely resembles original HP cartridges.
- •Recognized by printers immediately despite being remanufactured, avoiding compatibility headaches.
- •No leaks reported and prints initially flawless test pages and about 100 pages without streaks.
- •Welocumented instructions and troubleshooting guidance are included.
- •Reliable alternative to refilling or buying original HP cartridges at a lower price point.
Cons
- •Ink fading and poor cartridge performance can be inconsistent, with some users experiencing early ink fading after only about 10 pages.
- •Quality and performance may vary between different batches of cartridges.
- •Some cartridges were not recognized as "full" by printers, causing the printer to refuse to print.
- •Troubleshooting the recognition issues can be frustrating and timonsuming.
- •Ink quality and longevity are generally lower compared to original HP cartridges, especially for color cartridges (though this pack is black).
- •Printer may not print if it fails to detect the cartridge as full, leading to operational issues.
Bottom Line
The Valuetoner Remanufactured HP 98 (C9364WN) black ink cartridges are a budget-friendly alternative that can deliver solid performance, especially for casual or home use, with easy installation and generally reliable print quality early on. However, be prepared for some batch inconsistency and the risk of early ink fading or printer recognition issues that might require troubleshooting. If consistent OEM-like performance and hassle-free printing are top priorities, consider sticking with original HP cartridges or exploring other remanufactured options known for stability. If you're open to alternatives with possibly more consistent performance, feel free to ask, and we can help you find the best fit for your printer and needs.
Download ShopSavvy App
Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more
Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension
Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.
Footer 1
Subscribe for Updates
Get the latest news, and updates on ShopSavvy. You'll be glad you did!